Angie's List Tips > How to buy green flooring

Posted: 7/15/2009 3:20:07 PM | 39 comments
Bookmark and Share
Green flooring options are available to fit a variety of tastes and budgets. Here are a few things to consider before you invest in the popular products.

Look:
  • As far as colors and finishes go, there aren’t any major differences between green flooring and non-eco-friendly flooring. For some eco-friendly carpeting, the color is dyed into the chips that become the carpet yarn, which prevents fading over time.
Feel:
  • For carpeting, soft, eco-friendly fibers are more readily available to consumers than they have been in the past, but, as with most things, as the quality increases, so does the price tag.
Cost:
  • Wool carpeting is extremely eco-friendly, but comes with a higher price tag. If you’re looking for something green but not as pricey, Michael Lamendella, owner of Mr. Carpet Shop at Home in Chicago, has offered eco-friendly flooring since 2001 and says many of his customers have been fascinated with polyethylene terephthalate (PET) carpeting, which is made from recycled plastic bottles that are ground into little chips, melted and extruded into a fiber that is spun into a carpet yarn.
Maintenance:
  • Eco-friendly carpet requires the same attention as regular carpet.  Weekly vacuuming and annual cleanings will help ensure your carpet has a long, eco-friendly, life.
  • Bamboo flooring is easy to keep clean due to its natural resistance to water, moisture and stains.
  • Cork flooring requires slightly more care. According to Lamendella, spills on a cork floor must be wiped immediately.
Comments
Lori Guthrie
Please always consider if you are installing real wood floors, many do NOT have UV protection and it's common to have your wood floors FADE where heavy sunshine comes in.We installed a name brand and there is "0" warranty against fading.
7/16/2009 5:11:41 PM
Report abuse

Dawn
Lori,
That's a good tip. Does anyone know if bamboo flooring fades at the same rate as hardwood?
7/16/2009 5:28:21 PM
Report abuse

Peter
Our bamboo flooring is disappointingly prone to dents, knicks and scratches, which then fill with dirt. This despite manufacturers assurances supported by charts and tables proving that bamboo is just as hard as oak, blah blah blah. Otherwise bamboo is great!
7/16/2009 5:47:26 PM
Report abuse

Carla Kirkeby
I want to put down about 2,000 sq. ft. of vertical bamboo over plywood and joists on one level in my new house and wondered if anyone could recommend the best kind to buy.
7/16/2009 6:13:32 PM
Report abuse

Jan
For real oak floors, does anybody have objective ratings for oil-based vs water-based finishes?
7/16/2009 6:16:07 PM
Report abuse

Chris
About 90% of this article is about carpet - what about bamboo and cork?
7/16/2009 6:24:05 PM
Report abuse

maryg
I highly recommend cork flooring. If properly sealed, it is as water resistent as any wood floor. I installed it in my kitchen, where it gets plenty of wear and tear. After 3 years it still looks terrific. It is durable, requires very little care and is wonderfully easy on the feet. I also highly recommend Duro Design,a Canadian supplier, http://www.duro-design.com/. They do both cork and bamboo flooring. When I called about their cork flooring, they quickly sent me an "architect's sample" that had small samples of all 6 cork patterns and all 54 "standard" color choices. I then selected aroung 8 possibilities and they sent me full size tiles so I could make a final decision. I chose to use the tiles which were a breeze to install. The adhesive and the polyurethane for coating the tiles after installation was included in the cost of the tile. This company was GREAT to work with and the product selection offers some funky color and pattern choices -- in marked contrast to the uniformly dull choices on offer from American companies. I do not remember the exact cost, but do recall that it was comparable to good quality vinyl flooring -- and it is so much classier!
7/16/2009 6:48:59 PM
Report abuse

Richard
We've had high quality, hand scraped bamboo for about 2 years. It looks great, but it scratches very easily.
7/16/2009 8:44:52 PM
Report abuse

Tricia
bamboo seems to hold its color better than other woods. Here is a website that rates color change based on wood type
http://www.hardwoodinstaller.com/hardwoodinstaller/hardwood-floor-color-changes.htm
7/16/2009 9:00:27 PM
Report abuse

Stephanie
Sunlight will darken the finish on light bamboo. After about year, flooring underneath carpet or a rug will be visably lighter.
7/16/2009 9:31:31 PM
Report abuse

Diane
I have bamboo flooring and love it! Easy to clean and stays looking nice. I don't have direct sun hitting it. It actually seems to darken slightly with age.
7/16/2009 9:34:45 PM
Report abuse

Jean
Recent concerns about chemicals leaching from plastics may be an issue with body-contact products made from recycled plastics - like carpeting.
7/16/2009 9:40:15 PM
Report abuse

Sherrill Glick
We were dismayed to find that under the area rug on the bamboo floor, it was MUCH darker, so it seemed to fade quickly, however the room has a lot of windows.
7/16/2009 10:11:04 PM
Report abuse

Denise
Not sure if it fades but I wouldn't think so. I just installed vertical carbonized bamboo floors and they look fantastic...I'm also pretty sure that the strand-woven type of bamboo flooring doesn't fade either and it's a lot stronger than most flooring I've ever seen.
7/16/2009 11:45:17 PM
Report abuse

Donnie Peek
One problem with Bamboo flooring is that it destrands,especially the cheap stuff. You should look into buying American Made Eco-friendly Flooring like Antique Heart Pine,Antique Oak etc. There is alot of wood all over the country that would end up in landfills if not for companies like mine. Always try to Buy American! Bamboo Flooring is made in China. My Flooring is made in America.http://www.interstateflooringandstairs.com/index.html
7/17/2009 12:39:39 AM
Report abuse

Evanne Levin/ELG Design
Like other products, the degree and speed of bamboo flooring fading depends on how much light it is exposed to, how light/dark the material is when installed, and what finish may be on the wood. Neither my clients or I have noticed installed bamboo fading any faster than other wood floors but direct sunlight should be avoided as with any material, whether it be flooring or furnishings.
7/17/2009 2:25:27 AM
Report abuse

Evanne Levin/ELG Design
A caveat about wool carpeting:
While it is eco-friendly in the sense that it is a natural fiber and harms neither the animal nor the environment, persons sensitive to dust, hair, etc. might be wise to opt for flooring, with rugs as accents, as opposed to wall-to-wall carpeting.
7/17/2009 2:29:00 AM
Report abuse

Glenn Summers
Whatever flooring product you choose, consider that Any concrete, untreated will allow Moisture Vapor Emissions to surface in your home interior. This moisture collects under flooring causing adhesives to fail and mold to grow. In the case of a vinyl/rubberized material water can cause bubbles under the flooring. High humidity with A/C drawing moisture in through a concrete is a perscription for failures!
7/17/2009 6:12:16 AM
Report abuse

Charles Campbell
I had a company install a "solar
film" made by the 3m company on all my windows...It blocks and filters all harmful uv rays..It is really nice to open all blinds and see the world around you...and as an extra
benefit, during the day you can look out but no one can look in
if you choose the darker tints..
I no longer worry about anything fading by sun exposure
7/17/2009 7:26:49 AM
Report abuse

Robert Stacy
We have bamboo flooring, which I installed. It is light in color and EXTREMELY DURABLE. It is NOT prone to dents. I did a lot of research; the flooring I bought has 3 plies, all bamboo. A friend went to a cheaper product that has "Philippine Mahogany as the bottom two plies and it DOES dent. If the bamboo is not its natural color and has been "carbonized", it is MUCH softer.

On PET. PET is the most recyclable of all the plastics; it can be recycled many times.
It can be made into new bottles, containers and even fiber for clothing.
7/17/2009 10:29:26 AM
Report abuse

Glenn Sanders
Cork Flooring - Installed 1'x3' tongue/groove cork planks (very inexpensive and multiple color options from lumber liquidators) 1.5 years ago. Great for budgets and DIYers because it required no glue, no nails, no staples. We did use an optional moisture barrier and did seal afterwards but have had no problems, even though we rearrange our furniture about every 2 weeks!
7/17/2009 11:35:58 AM
Report abuse

Chris K.
The usual vertical and horizontal bamboo are fairly strong, but the newer strand woven variety is much more dense and much more resistant to wear. It looks like strand woven bamboo will be the new gold standard for durable flooring.
7/17/2009 1:31:36 PM
Report abuse

Jeanette Carpenter
We put cork in our bedroom and love it! I have allergies and asthma, and not only is it hypoallergenic, but cork is warmer and quieter than wood, and also softer on the feet. On cold nights it really makes a difference! We plan to pull out that gross carpet in the other bedrooms and put in cork. It is surprisingly hard and the complex design won't show dents anyway. We did it ourselves using 1'X3' planks.
7/17/2009 4:47:55 PM
Report abuse

Amy
We are looking to replace carpeting with either hardwood, bamboo, or cork floors. We have three medium to large dogs. Does anyone have experience with dogs on cork or bamboo floors?
7/18/2009 3:50:35 PM
Report abuse

Marilyn Ray
I have several rooms to be re-floored, and I prefer to save $$ by doing it myself. I will NOT consider carpeting of any way, shape, or form...because I have 3 indoor dogs (2 small, one VERY large), and carpeting in my part of the country (Pacific Northwest) soon wears, and collects DIRT underneath over time, what with the pets tracking in mud,, etc.

Solution? From the post readings here today, I am leaning toward CORK flooring, and was impressed by the post that suggested an out-of-area cork dealer with excellent customer service.

Being a widow on a fixed income, I must have an easy-to-install, reasonably priced product that can withstand the dogs AND cats at my place.

Your thinking?? Thanks
7/20/2009 7:50:49 PM
Report abuse

Yvonne
Thanks for the comments on cork flooring! You have answered all my questions about installing it in my master bath.
7/21/2009 2:39:36 PM
Report abuse

chris
What about stone/epoxy floors? I'm getting an estimate on one for my basement (which is prone to occasional wetness). Any other flooring will just go out on the curb--not very eco.
7/21/2009 5:40:00 PM
Report abuse

Heather
We too installed cork over the entire household. It was easy to install and BEAUTIFUL. The ooohhss and ahhhss don't stop when people come over. It has been unbelievably durable which is contrary to the stuff I read previously on-line. I would definitely install it again. We purchased ours from I-floor and it was at a price as cheap or cheaper than hardwood options.
7/22/2009 10:01:40 AM
Report abuse

Sharon
We have had bamboo flooring in our bedroom for 3 years and we love it. Easy to clean, nice and cool in the summers and throw rugs work great in the winter. We have 3 black labs. They are not allowed in the room anymore. They did leave scratches from their toenails.
7/23/2009 11:23:06 AM
Report abuse

JC
We have cork in our sunroom. The BEST option, easy on feet, neutral temp even in winter. It has faded some but because of the varied and interesting bark patterns it still has a lot of dark areas and interest and the fading is not that dramatic. We have a black lab and his nails have never scratched it. He did chew on a bone once and his chewing kept going and he chewed a small patch/thin-layer off the top of the cork. But even that spot just looks like the pattern in the cork and no one can even see it. In fact it took us a long time before we saw it and realized what that little area was! We love it.
7/30/2009 8:19:16 PM
Report abuse

Nate
To Jan who wrote: Jan
For real oak floors, does anybody have objective ratings for oil-based vs water-based finishes?
7/16/2009 6:16:07 PM

I highly recommend John Sagstetters EcoFloor coatings for oak floors. He runs JB Floors and has a water based coating which he applied in our home in Feb. 2009 and we love it.
8/19/2009 11:57:52 AM
Report abuse

kathie
Am looking at different type flooring for my basement. After reading all comments I believe I'll seriously consider cork flooring. Have a dog who loves to run in the house as well as out, and brings in lots of water and snow with her. The basement is a walkout with lots of light also. Will let you know how things work out.
9/3/2009 1:18:17 PM
Report abuse

jess
We bought PET (recycled bottle) carpeting last year. Because we have pets, keeping it clean was a concern. We couldn't be happier with it. Stains come out with plain water, and it looks lovely.
9/18/2009 12:45:57 AM
Report abuse

tom
I read through this blog and was pretty surprised to hear cork standing up to dogs. I would really appreciate any more feedback on whether that changed or not.
Also, does anyone have radiant floor heating with cork over it?
Regarding bamboo, I have 2 dogs and between their scratches and some FLOR brand tiles, I'm ready to rip it out. The color definitely darkened which I didn't mind, but it's as light as new under the FLOR rugs and it was really painful to put in over a slab.
I'm leaning toward either the cork or a more durable reclaimed hardwood.
Thoughts?
9/18/2009 2:22:40 PM
Report abuse

steve zagoski
I just had a bamboo floor put in. I was recomended by two of my neighbors. The floor looks incredible and the work was done quick. I live my new floor. Its easy to clean and seems to be pretty durable so far. i highly recomend the bamboo floor as well as the company that put it in.
10/23/2009 5:41:43 PM
Report abuse

sue
Best eco friendly finish for wood floors: I refinished hardwood and used Osmo Polyx Oil. I love the way it looks, it has worn well, can be spot refinished and is low in toxicity. Highly reommended
12/21/2009 8:30:27 AM
Report abuse

Ask Roxanne
I specify and sell bamboo flooring as well as cork tiles and plank floors. They are both very smart choices for not only beautiful, but durable floors. I discuss in more detail the benefits of bamboo flooring in my latest blog post. I will be discussing the benefits of cork in a follow up discussion on environmentally friendly building products.
Roxanne
1/23/2010 10:09:01 AM
Report abuse

Carol
Bamboo can vary. It is considered a hardwood, but if you get on the Hardwood Institute's site and want to know the hardness of any species- you get a #. Not so with bamboo. In my opinion it's one of the most overstated by uninformed sales reps out there. In addition-- the trend now is toward life cycle. It's not enough to make a product out of a rapidly renewing resource like bamboo. It must be a long lasting product, be manufactured in sustainable ways, with no added urea formaldyhe. There are some, but very few importers of this product adhere to these standards. Most will pit as other posters have stated-- so socks only. I speak on "green building" as I was a founder of the Co Chapter, US Green Building Council. Some, not all, manufacturers of bamboo take a very green product- -and just muck it up!
2/17/2010 5:03:17 PM
Report abuse

Carol
Now to reply about Cork. Many enviro groups consider cork the best sustainable product for flooring. It is very long lasting and made in a very enviro conscious way. The tree is not cut down but stripped of it's bark. This can only be done every 10 years, these trees are revered. I have an associate who was in a church built in 1902 with the original cork floors. I was in a university almost that old. I'm full of warnings about bamboo, but lush on cork.
2/17/2010 5:05:54 PM
Report abuse

Leave comment



 Security code