Angie's List Tips > February 2009 > When to keep a sick child home

Posted: 2/23/2009 5:23:56 PM | 26 comments
Bookmark and Share
A sniffling, coughing, achy child can be a conundrum for parents. Where do you draw the line between keeping them at home (and, possibly, taking off work to take care of them) and sending them to school?  

The American Academy of Pediatrics says that some of it depends on the child. As long as they’re not contagious, some children may feel like they can still buckle down, concentrate and participate, others may be fatigued and require some extra TLC.

If they’re contagious, they should be at home so they don’t spread the germs to their classmates.
Other things to consider:
  • Keep an eye on the thermometer. A temperature of 100 or above should warrant heavy consideration for bed patrol and plenty of fluids.
  • Make sure they can keep down food and drinks. Vomiting and/or diarrhea can be telltale signs of the flu in children. The flu is highly contagious, and should be checked by a doctor as soon as symptoms appear.
  • Watch their energy level. “Healthy children learn better,” says Amy Garcia, Executive Director of the National Association of School Nurses. Excessive tiredness, lack of appetite or achiness won’t make for an abundantly productive school day.
  • Don’t load up on medicines. The FDA recently voted that no data supports the use of cough and cold medicines in children between the ages of two to six, and that these products should never be given to children under the age of two.
“The cough suppressants do not work to suppress cough; the decongestants do not work to reduce congestion,” says Dr. Michael Shannon, a pediatric emergency medicine physician and pharmacologist/toxicologist at Children's Hospital Boston. “The good news is that a cold will last three to four days and then their child will be fine.”

If your child has a fever or feels achy, Shannon recommends use of acetaminophen or ibuprofen, which are known to be safe and effective in children.
  • Take sore throats seriously. A minor sore throat is common, but a severely sore throat could be a sign of strep throat, even if there is no fever. Be on the lookout for headaches and upset stomach, which can also be signs of strep. If you notice multiple symptoms, consult your doctor.
  • Don’t ship them back to school too soon. Keep sick kids home until they’ve gone 24 hours without a fever (without medication). Returning to school too soon can hamper the recovery process and expose their classmates to germs.
Most people recover from the flu within a week, but may be left feeling exhausted for as long as three to four weeks.
  • Know your company’s policies. You may need to consider telecommuting or finding a relative or sitter to stay with your sick child if you can’t take the time (or afford to take time) off work.
  • Plan in advance: Before the cold and flu season hit, get flu shots for the whole family to help prevent unnecessary illness.
“It usually takes a couple of weeks from the time you get the shot to be fully protected," says Dr. Thomas Sandora, medical director of Infection Control at Children's Hospital Boston "but flu activity tends to continue through at least March.”
 
Comments
Kathy
A child with a runny nose or a cough can be contagious, even with no fever. That same child can make a classmate so sick that he/she ends up in the hospital or medication. If a child is exhibiting symptoms (runny nose, cough) and hasn't been determined by a physician to be not contagious (i.e., chronic allergies), that child needs to be kept home. Otherwise, the rest of us suffer.
2/24/2009 1:02:01 PM
Report abuse

Emily
It drives me nuts when people send sick kids to school just because they don't want to miss work or whatever else they have planned. . I see kids with hacking coughs, strep, constantly running (green) snotty noses, etc. and hear things like "she was throwing up yesterday, but she's fine this morning," or "she has diarrhea, but it's just because she ate too much fruit." How do you know? Why take the chance of infecting others? People need to consider that their child could infect other families and it will be a major inconvenience for them.

Kids WILL get sick, and parents need to have a plan. If I worked, I would plan on using some of my vacation time to stay home with sick kids. Employers need to become more family-friendly, too.

Someone should start an emergency nanny service for sick kids so that people don't have to send them back to school when they are not ready.
2/24/2009 1:45:13 PM
Report abuse

Dr. Dave
Please stop using the word "flu" for vomiting and/or diarrhea. Real flu is influenza, and its symptoms include high fever, body aches, and cough (and is prevented by the flu shot you mention in the last paragraph.)
2/24/2009 2:37:23 PM
Report abuse

Laura
A cough can last for weeks. It is not reasonable to keep kids home that whole time. If there is no fever and they are over the worst of it I think it's ok to send them back. A common cold takes a week to 10 days to finish - no one stays in isolation that long.
2/24/2009 4:23:09 PM
Report abuse

Michael
Kathy is absolutely correct! However, most people are so selfish that they do what is best for them (send the sick to school or go to work sick) with utter disregard for others.
2/24/2009 5:01:29 PM
Report abuse

Bev
Staying home from work, with your sick child is what should happen. However many employers require a doctor's note before allowing an employee to use sick time, and how many folks can afford to take their child to the doctor for every cold? Federal law should at least guarentee a parent a certain number of unpaid child sick days with no doctor's not required.
2/24/2009 5:24:40 PM
Report abuse

Tracy
I very much agree with the above ladies...we have abandoned our bodies need for rest when we are sick! Modern medicine developed supressive drugs to get laborers back to work faster so they could feed their families (1900-1930's)
Please give yours and your childrens bodies time to heal, away from healthy individuals.
2/24/2009 8:22:40 PM
Report abuse

Jeff
With bulletpoint #4 above in mind ("no data supports the use of cough and cold medicines in children between the ages of two to six"), does the effectiveness of these medicines magically 'kick-in' later in life, or are we all deceiving ourselves?
2/24/2009 9:00:13 PM
Report abuse

Christopher
It's not just children, last week we had a PARENT who came to school coughing all over the place. She sat right next to the snack table and coughed as well, and this week our whole family, including my pregnant wife, is sick. Coincidence? I want to throttle the inconsiderate selfish woman.
2/25/2009 12:55:54 AM
Report abuse

Jo Anne
Amen! to Emily's comments. I'm a teacher and I couldn't have said it better myself. Parents who knowingly send their sick children to school are selfish, thoughtless and irresponsible. Yet I see it again and again. No one said that parenting was going to be easy or convenient all the time.
2/25/2009 7:09:46 AM
Report abuse

Gramma Elaine
Flu shots are very ineffective and only profit the drug companies - see Dr. Sherri Tenpenny's site: http://www.nmaseminars.com. In my opinion, Vitamin D3 is a much better choice to prevent flu. Also avoid processed foods containing man-made chemicals that make the body more susceptible to viruses and germs. Whole foods = good health!
2/25/2009 10:14:14 AM
Report abuse

PA Mary
Unfortunately, so many "pink collar" and other part-time and lower paying jobs don't even offer sick leave for employees, let alone for their children's illness. Naturally, these are the very people who can least afford an unpaid day off. (NPR did a great piece on this in the last week or so.)
2/25/2009 12:44:50 PM
Report abuse

Debra
How do you know that your child is NOT contagious? No fever? For how long? For a cold, within a certain amount of time from onset? This would really help and is not always obvious.
2/26/2009 7:33:05 PM
Report abuse

Meg
Here's the unconventional wisdom: Truly healthy people don't get sick, even when surrounded by illness. The problem is that so many people today are not really healthy, and it's so much easier to blame others when they get sick (plus our culture encourages that mentality). That aside, yes, it is important to rest when ill. The body can take care of most problems when supported properly. A big part of that support is sufficient rest, which I realize is very hard for people in particular industries to obtain, either for themselves or their children when sick. It's a vicious cycle.
2/26/2009 8:30:58 PM
Report abuse

Chris MD
Please correct the second bullet point. Vomiting and diarrhea are signs of gastroenteritis, which can be highly contagious. Influenza, or "the flu," is a respiratory illness with fever and respiratory symptoms. Influenza can be prevented by giving the flu shot to everyone in the house over six months old.
2/27/2009 7:27:12 PM
Report abuse

nanner
In the best of all possible worlds, a parent or other caretaker should stay home with a sick child - both to help the child recover and to limit contagion. Some hospitals offer a sick-child service - for a fee of course - if a parent absolutely has to go to work.
I think this applies to adults as well who think they are showing their mettle by coming to work when they are ill. The rest of us do not appreciate that and the opportunity to bring home an illness to our families.
3/1/2009 10:07:01 PM
Report abuse

Lori
AMEN! As a former teacher, I saw lots of violations of the health code and schools' rules. These should be posted and enforced!
3/2/2009 1:15:35 PM
Report abuse

Ethan Pharmacist
Wake up people. Decongestants and cough suppressants really do not help children. They delude parents into thinking they are doing something right. Vitamins do not help colds or the flu, either. If you get the flu or a cold, you are going to be sick. There is no magic spell that will make everything disappear. The best thing is a cool vapor humidifier placed next to the bed of the sick child. That loosens the mucous, which helps the cough and reduces the congestion. THAT is the best thing to do. Use plain distilled water. Do NOT use vaporizer chemicals that stink up the room. They are WORTHLESS. In these tiomes of economic hardship, you do not need to WASTE your money on something that will NOT work anyway.
3/2/2009 10:55:39 PM
Report abuse

NOELLE
As a High School teacher, I've seen some kids take off school every time they have a sniffle or a cough, much to their own detriment. Most students don't have tutors visiting them to keep them caught up with the school curriculum. These comments reflect a privileged position in this society of ours. When everyone in this country has job security and paid family leave, then taking an unlimited number of days off so that children can sleep off their viruses will be possible. Until then, the condescending expectation that no sick person will encroach your personal space should be checked at the border.
3/3/2009 10:59:19 PM
Report abuse

tmullins
We have a MRSA problem in my area, Methicillan Resistant Staphylococcus Aureaus. It used to be a hospital acquired infection but is in our schools, homes, restaurants, churches, etc. The health departments can't seem to understand or figure out how MRSA is being spread. Have any of you heard about or dealt with an experience with this disease ?
3/9/2009 4:43:36 AM
Report abuse

Joyce MS, CRNP
I am a nurse practitioner in a pediatric emergency department at an academic teaching center. I have a few responses to the previous comments. We do not consider a child to have a fever unless the thermometer reaches 100.4 degrees. A child may have a low grade fever by over-dressing or being in an environment that is too hot. I tell parents no school until no temperature for 24 hours. Vomiting and diarrhea will usually last a week. Parents should wash their hands or use a skin sanitizer after contact with vomit or stool. If there is vomiting alone, call your pediatrician. Flu shots work. Go the the American Academy of Peds. web site for more healthcare tips (www.aap.org). I am in Baltimore, MD which has the highest incidence of MRSA in the country. For more information, read: http://www.cdc.gov/mrsa/mrsa_initiative/skin_infection/index.html
3/11/2009 10:16:09 PM
Report abuse

suzettte
To the Emily's (2-24-09), JoAnne's(2-25-09) and Lori's( 3-2-09)out there, THERE IS and has been an established child care service 24/7 only a phone call away to help and avoid all of your and many others concerns about sick children among our healthy children. Your Other Hands is an EXCELLENT nanny service who sends caring nurturing women to your home, in your child's own environment all while offering TLC. If a child is too sick to attend school, let them stay in their own beds sleep till they wake, while a professional care giver tends to their meals, aches & pains, whether for a day or a week. If your child is just getting sick nip it in the bud keep them home one day to avoid missing the week. Highly recommended by so many. Just ask any pediatrian. They never even advertise that’s how good they are. They come through for you.
3/13/2009 1:16:04 PM
Report abuse

anne
If kids stayed home every time they have a runny nose or cough they'd be home all winter long. It's very hard to tell when a kid is contagious, often it's before they show symptoms, and thick green snot is actually less contagious than clear mucus. (Per the CDC: "When germs that cause colds first infect the nose and sinuses, the nose makes clear mucus. This helps wash the germs from the nose and sinuses. After two or three days, the body’s immune cells fight back, changing the mucus to a white or yellow color. As the bacteria that live in the nose grow back, they may also be found in the mucus, which changes the mucus to a greenish color.") I wish that the article spoke more to hand washing and cleaning, which I understand to be the best prevention for spreading viruses.
3/18/2009 4:52:56 PM
Report abuse

Kathy
Anne, unfortunately hand washing is no help with young children in preschools and daycares. One to three year olds can't remember to keep their hands away from their eyes/nose/mouth. If one of them is sick, the rest get sick. With one teacher per 5 (or more) kids, the adult can't wash fast enough to prevent it, either. If ALL kids stayed home every time they had a runny nose or cough, they wouldn't spread the germs, and all of us would be sick a lot less often!!!
3/20/2009 1:15:11 PM
Report abuse

Marvin
Unfortunately some parents do not have the option of staying home instead of working, or they would lose the job completely. This is very bad policy, but nothing they can do to correct it. So these parents must find someone who can stay with the children, but cannot afford to pay them either. The only other option may be to go bankrupt and/or lose their homes.
3/24/2009 4:47:11 PM
Report abuse

Kelli
Kathy - that is not true. Washing hands IS a help regardless of age.

I find it amusing that many people extolling the fact that kids should stay home even with the sniffles are also people who say "well...if I had a job..." it is easy to say what you would/would not do when you don't have to make that decision.

Seriously sick and knowingly/most likely contagious children should be kept home. As Anne said, if you kept a child home every time the sniffles came about, I would have to take off of work the months of October through April.
10/7/2009 3:30:28 PM
Report abuse

Leave comment



 Security code